Connect and collaborate with football enthusiasts from around the world in all football medicine related disciplines.
Share your work and thoughts, find the research you need to help your work and join open discussions with the authors and other experts.

Share This Post

Featured / News / Research Papers

Why aren’t athletes more forthcoming about their concussion symptoms?

Why aren’t athletes more forthcoming about their concussion symptoms?

By shgmom56 on Flickr (Originally posted to Flickr as “DSC02769”) [CC BY-SA 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Clinicians are acutely aware of the increased visibility and concern about concussive injury during sport, especially during soccer. Soccer is unique because of the purposeful use of the head to control and advance the ball and because this skill places the player in a vulnerable situation that exposes the head to potential injury, especially during heading duels.

Players, coaches, parents, and clinicians have one important task when a suspected injury happens and that is to identify that a concussive injury might have occurred. The problem with concussion is there are few signs that help everyone involved make that determination. Thus, the evaluation must rely on subjective responses by the player and that the player is being honest about reporting any symptoms. When a player is less than truthful about their symptoms, the player might be returned to play without sufficient time for the brain to recover. So, why might a player not be forthcoming with their symptoms either on the day of the injury or during the recovery period after injury?

Chrisma et al. sought to determine the barriers that prevent a player from revealing their symptoms by performing a qualitative study of 50 high school athletes (Seattle, Washington area; football, boys soccer, girls soccer divided into 9 groups). Professional focus group moderators followed a standard script that discussed concussion knowledge and the athlete’s responses to four hypothetical scenarios. The players were able to describe multiple signs and symptoms of concussion, understood the dangers of concussions, and players from all focus groups were aware of the possibility of death or long term disability. When challenged with situations involving concussive symptoms, however, athletes said they would not stop playing. Instead, they would either continue playing (6 of the 9 groups) or would take a short break and then return to the game (3 of the 9 groups).

There were a number of barriers that explained the athlete’s replies. For example, the athletes wanted to remain in the game and reporting symptoms might lead to their removal from the game. Or, because concussive symptoms are nonspecific, they could be mistaken to have been caused by some other reason. Finally, athletes did not want to report symptoms to coaches unless there was some obvious pain or disability. Based on the responses, it appears that athletes have adequate concussion knowledge and lack of understanding of the injury is not a barrier. Coach approachability, however, may be an issue behind players not reporting their symptoms. The authors though that improving player-coach communication regarding concussion might remove this barrier and improve the reporting of symptom by athletes.

Chrisman SP, C Quitiquit, FP Rivara.
Qualitative Study of Barriers to Concussive Symptom Reporting in High School Athletics.
J Adolesc Health 2013; 52:330-335. [PubMed]

Share This Post

Don Kirkendall
Don is a lifelong player and licensed coach with a PhD in exercise science who continued his love of The Beautiful Game’ by studying soccer on multiple levels. With over 80 published peer-reviewed publications, many focused on soccer, Don brings a broad perspective on training, nutrition, and specific topics in football medicine. He sits on the US Soccer Sports Medicine Advisory Committee.

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of
avatar

Would you like to receive our monthly Newsletter? 

If you want to be included in our e-mail list for this newsletter, we will need to have your name and e-mail address.

Subscribe NOW and get fresh monthly news!

We will respect the confidentiality of this information and will not pass on your email details to any other person or institution.

Thank you for sending!